Further thoughts on study regarding human dignity & data as an asset

Is “personal data” an asset? A study on human dignity & data protection has been released that on paper sounds like it should cover all the key topics. Its authors argue that individuals are “the primary right-holders in relation to the processing of their personal data” and that these “are dignity-relevant manifestations of the person […]

Read Analysis →

Study on human dignity and limits to processing of personal data: first thoughts

Interesting study on where human dignity and data protection come together, worth the read. I’m not convinced by some parts, though, as there is too much room left for subjectivity in the way certain things are worded. The authors suggest 7 guiding principles, but of particular interest to me were their suggested 6 limits to […]

Read Analysis →

Digital Omnibus draft: critical review of Council draft compromise

Some thoughts on the leaked EU Council draft compromise re the GDPR parts of the Digital Omnibus: – This draft reads as a major lobbying win by data protection authorities and civil society. The EDPB would be given more power, the Commission no supervision, and a lot of the more business-friendly proposals would be removed […]

Read Analysis →

LLMs & personal data: distinguishing probability from identification

A new study on LLMs & personal data (by Dimitri Staufer and Kirsten Morehouse) can be read in two ways: 1. Some will see it as validation that LLMs process personal data because they seem to be capable of associating attributes with a person with a certain % of confidence. 2. I see it instead […]

Read Analysis →

Making the GDPR realistic? Authorities only want that in part

[This is a translation of an op-ed in French that was published in the French journal Revue Politique on SRB and the Digital Omnibus, plus the newest EDPB & EDPS Joint Opinion on the topic. The original in French can be found on the Revue Politique website. + The banner image is a jest – […]

Read Analysis →

Revue Politique: op-ed on move towards realism in GDPR interpretation

Pour les francophones: I was given the opportunity to write an op-ed for the French journal Revue Politique on SRB and the Digital Omnibus, plus the newest EDPB & EDPS Joint Opinion on the topic. The result? “Rendre le RGPD réaliste ? Les autorités ne le souhaitent qu’à moitié”. I’m working on a translation into […]

Read Analysis →

EDPB stakeholder engagement: some light on the horizon?

I criticise them a lot for many things, notably their often dogmatic and not-so-pragmatic positions, but kudos to the European Data Protection Board for two things today: (i) they actually sent a reminder to participants for the “Political ads” stakeholder event of 27 March to ask if people wish to speak on particular topics or […]

Read Analysis →

Scientific research: definition and commercial limits

Under which circumstances does the GDPR consider scientific research compatible with existing purposes of personal data processing? Recent positions by regulators and legislators show it is still a hot topic – one with major implications for R&D globally. Recital 159 of the GDPR states that “the processing of personal data for scientific research purposes should […]

Read Analysis →

Perspectives on EDPB & EDPS Joint Opinion on Digital Omnibus

Some thoughts (+ & -) on the EDPB & EDPS’s joint opinion on the GDPR & ePrivacy Digital Omnibus, part 1: + The overall tone seems constructive – On the definition of personal data (PD), I don’t think quoting the Scania/SRB situation of information being “indirectly” PD for a disclosing party (§16) helps the EDPB/EDPS’s […]

Read Analysis →

Possibility to challenge EDPB decisions: a win for accountability

Very glad to see the EU Court of Justice confirm that EDPB binding decisions are challengeable, like the Advocate General had suggested beforehand. I commented the AG Opinion at the time, applauding it for its clear position in the topic. The CJEU’s reasoning is very similar to that of the AG: – “[the EDPB’s binding […]

Read Analysis →