Why means of identification and actual influence shape joint controllership after Breyer

Breyer seemingly confirmed (means of identification are crucial), facts matter re establishment of joint controllership (it depends on whether there is actual influence and an own purpose), and joint controllership doesn’t necessarily extend to further processing (such as advertising) – we will be looking at the CJEU’s newest judgment (C-604/22 – IAB Europe / TCF […]

Read Analysis →

Why server connection telemetry isn’t automatically personal data under the GDPR

Another adtech discussion showing that not all information gleaned through server connections is personal data under the GDPR (or even the CCPA’s broad “personal information” concept). [Nor is it / should it be automatically covered by ePrivacy rules] In this case, it was about which data points are actually being used, by whom and who […]

Read Analysis →

How the upcoming CJEU ruling will define automated decision-making under Article 22

What is automated decision-making? This is what the CJEU is asked in case C-634/21. In an Opinion delivered today, Advocate General Pikam�e proposed an answer. Art. 22 GDPR says that a data subject [DS] can only be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing that produces legal effects concerning him/her or �similarly significantly […]

Read Analysis →

A useful Belgian DPA ruling outlining the practical limits of data subject access

Useful new decision by the Belgian Data Protection Authority on the limits of data subject access requests, in a case where a data subject complained that the response was (i) late and (ii) incomplete. (i) Late response: The response was late due to a long-term absence of the person normally managing data subject requests due […]

Read Analysis →

Deconstructing the logical flaws in noyb’s automotive consent or pay allegory

Getting some serious “You wouldn’t steal a car”* vibes from NOYB’s “Imagine having to pay for privacy in your own car” consent-or-pay allegory. I have been advising on the idea of “consent or pay” (or “pay or data”, “pay or OK” or however you wish to call it) for a few years now, and the […]

Read Analysis →

Which GDPR legal ground applies when broadcasting recognizable persons?

Which GDPR legal ground does a broadcaster or streaming platform need to publish audiovisual works featuring recognisable natural persons? That was the question examined by the Belgian DPA in its latest decision. The decision related to a kind of documentary, a “human interest” show/programme. The BDPA’s Litigation Chamber summarised the facts as follows (para. 2 […]

Read Analysis →

Why a new Belgian DPA decision reinforces the true primacy of EU law

In its newest decision, the Belgian DPA takes a stance that will please both consumer rights organisations and anyone who likes to rely on the primacy of EU legislation (versus local national legislation), on an issue that would not have arisen if the Belgian legislator had stuck to the text of the GDPR. This all […]

Read Analysis →

Op-Ed: If AI replaces work for junior lawyers, what happens next?

“AI won’t replace you – a lawyer who uses it will” is quickly becoming a cliché – but what about junior lawyers and the next generation(s)? A newly published study on legal contract review brings this question again into focus (Better Call GPT, Comparing Large Language Models Against Lawyers), as it concludes that “LLMs perform […]

Read Analysis →

Why the corporate data protection community needs a stronger voice against campaigners

The privacy discourse is often one-sided: regulators and campaigners are vocal (“fundamental rights violated”, “illegal consent”), and few want to push back in public (lawyers because they are not keen on voicing their opinion, businesses because they fear drawing attention to themselves) – even though the GDPR *allows* interferences with privacy and data protection rights […]

Read Analysis →

Catch up on online advertising, cookie consent, and ePrivacy via this podcast episode

Fancy catching up on some of the issues regarding onlineadvertising, ePrivacy, the GDPR, data as a commodity, cookieless and consent? Listen to this podcast episode in which I presented a different angle on these topics (and more). privacy data protection

Read Analysis →